asked Apr 23 '10

Hexhead
93 ● 4 ● 6 ● 10

I personally love commenting as a way to extend and enhance a Q/A conversation.. which is different than answering a Q of course.. please consider a robust commenting function which includes multiple comments in each Q/A thread and email alerts if the user comments on someone else's thread.. Thanks

Comments

hey, could you try editing my answer? I hope it works - made it CW. Evgeny (Apr 23 '10)

3 Answers

Sort by » oldest newest most voted

Hexhead has selected this answer as correct

answered Apr 23 '10

This post is a wiki. Anyone with karma >100 is welcome to improve it.

updated Apr 23 '10

Evgeny

6665 ● 31 ● 49 ● 95
http://askbot.org/

I've just lowered the barrier for commenting to 1 (used to be 50) and edit wiki posts to 30 points.

Why don't we use this post to formulate requirements for the commenting tool? Currently user with less points than the commenting barrier can comment only own posts and answers to own questions. Comments are very simple - no internal formatting, you can only add and delete them (depending on reputation).

Feature requests:

email and on-screen alerts to relevant users

link

answered Feb 26 '11

locomo
51 ● 2 ● 4

I don't think I have enough points yet to improve the wiki so I guess I'll post this here for now.

Feature request: - up/down vote on comments

link

answered May 16 '11

Olaf
11 ● 1 ● 3
http://oberprima.com/

updated May 16 '11

I'm new to askbot, received 1 Point for signing up, but I'm still unable to comment (or too blind to find it ;)) Can anybody help me?

edit: Right after posting this comments, I saw the commenting feature under my own post - so I will try and checkout, if I'm able to comment other peoples questions as well

link

Comments

So far it seems as if I'm only able to comment on my own posts... Olaf (May 16 '11)

Only in the beginning, default minimum rep to comment anywhere is 50, but it can be changed in the settings. Evgeny (May 16 '11)

Thanks Evgeny - We're planning to use askbot as "core" for OberPrima.com. Olaf (May 16 '11)

Question tools

1 follower

Stats

Asked: Apr 23 '10

Seen: 654 times

Last updated: May 17 '11

Commenting feature request

Comments

3 Answers

Comments

Your answer

Question tools

Stats

Related questions