Ask Your Question
4

Should added comments bump question to the top of the recently active list?

asked 2010-07-07 18:22:05 -0600

Evgeny gravatar image

updated 2010-07-09 14:08:10 -0600

What do you think, should "last updated" time record be updated when a new comment is added to question or answer?

If that field is updated, then most recently commented questions (or questions whose answers were rencently commented) will appear on the top in the default question listing. Is this a good thing?

edit retag flag offensive close merge delete

Comments

Are there still plans to implement this? It looks like posting a comment still does not count as "activity" on my hosted site.

todofixthis gravatar imagetodofixthis ( 2012-04-25 21:58:43 -0600 )edit

4 Answers

Sort by » oldest newest most voted
2

answered 2011-06-26 04:10:03 -0600

mether gravatar image

I would say so but I am wondering if the same questions would always hog the top list and push away unanswered questions

edit flag offensive delete link more

Comments

2
If this was a site option, I would be willing to try it out and see if it makes the community more vibrant.
mether gravatar imagemether ( 2011-07-25 00:05:41 -0600 )edit

You can always select the "Unanswered" questions tab.

powlo gravatar imagepowlo ( 2012-04-30 17:14:55 -0600 )edit

Yes, because some questions have high "activity". And if I resurrect an old thread by commenting, there has been "activity" and it will appear on the frontpage. I can't do that under the current system.

Joseph gravatar imageJoseph ( 2012-07-14 03:28:28 -0600 )edit

Most OSQA sites are low activity, so showing as much activity as possible is important. For high activity site, there should be a "sort by coolness" or "sort by freshness" but doing that right is trickier.

Joseph gravatar imageJoseph ( 2012-07-14 03:30:19 -0600 )edit
2

answered 2011-09-26 23:28:33 -0600

sagarun gravatar image

updated 2011-09-26 23:29:04 -0600

I will work on this,

  1. we can have a setting that says "recently commented on top"
  2. If the settings is enabled, we can make the front page show recently commented questions first!

Any thoughts?

edit flag offensive delete link more

Comments

That's fine, but there is a bug in the send_email_alerts management command, which will be sending alerts about changes in the comments, which you don't always want. Basically to make this feature - we need to rewrite the send_email_alerts management command, which is anyway very slow. It needs better algorighthm.

Evgeny gravatar imageEvgeny ( 2011-09-27 07:48:12 -0600 )edit
0

answered 2012-04-30 14:41:19 -0600

luyu gravatar image

What do you think of adding new "Sort by" value called "comments" which would, when clicked on, sort questions by most (or least on second click) recently posted comments in them? This shouldn't change current behavior of sorting by activity.

It could also be mixed with solution @sagarun proposed, which would then serve as a mechanism for admins to choose whether sort by activity or comments would be site default. Option can be added in user profile too to change this setting on individual basis.

edit flag offensive delete link more
0

answered 2013-06-09 02:10:20 -0600

pajju gravatar image

updated 2013-06-11 03:21:47 -0600

I contemplated with my team on this feature.

My view is —

The current version of askbot is cool! i.e Don't sort your site front-page by comments.

  • The front-page should be un-biased, as its a QnA site, so comments should be of little importance to any QnA site growth, otherwise it kills the basic essence of the site.

  • Hitting the front-page should purely be function of — value generated, so sort by trending activity — think upvotes and update by answers.

Note: Askbot is not a commenting site or any typical forum like phpBB, so giving comments a push to the site front-page, will kill the value of QnA sites.

  • So, the Homepage should NOT be sorted by recent-most comments at any cost. May be, lets have another filter, sort by recent-most comments?

    • The problem with sort by comment activity is — such filtering by recent-most comments will bring older stale topics to the front-page again. Frontpage should be like News and updates. (Think HN)

Also in Askbot, if you have engaged in a thread, you would have followed that question to get notified! A user can also do @user to bring another user's attention.

Comments are largely single-dimensional — are targeted one-on-one or sometimes for self-clarifications(ie single dimensional). So getting the whole-community-attention for some random comment update is not Cool! Comments should NOT be broadcasted.

  • Personally, I don't like to bring posts on front-page, unless it's of value — it has good answers.

Comments are more like discussions, not multi-dimensional and kind of opinionated. So it becomes discussion site.

But, Answers = generates value!

And by just dropping a comment to hit front-page, will push anyone's question easily to hit front-page. Think old stale questions and non-trending topics hitting Front-page often.

One Possible Solution: Maybe we can have another filter like — sort by>> recent-comments.

But this filter should NOT be the default filter for sorting questions in the homepage.

Thanks.

PS: I'm not a big fan of comments for Askbot kind of QnA sites. :)

edit flag offensive delete link more

Comments

The OSQA ask site we formerly used and ran treated comments as activity, and essentially everyone I know who used the site liked and preferred that behavior over the current treatment of comments with our new Askbot site. In our view, comments are activity and do provide value. I understand after reading the answers and comments posted here that not everyone agrees with that. Fair enough. It would be really nice if we could be given the choice of whether to include comments as activity or not though, because many of us do desire that exact behavior. Please reconsider and add an option that would cause comments to be included in activity. Thanks for reading.

cmaynard gravatar imagecmaynard ( 2017-12-01 15:47:38 -0600 )edit

Your Answer

Please start posting anonymously - your entry will be published after you log in or create a new account.

Add Answer

Question Tools

2 followers

Stats

Asked: 2010-07-07 18:22:05 -0600

Seen: 1,607 times

Last updated: Jun 11 '13